Members of the Blue Ribbon Commission on Public Education spent Oct. 19 working through possible recommendations on how North Carolina school districts handle finance, hiring, purchasing, and other back-office functions. Regional shared services drew the most support across three small-group discussions.
The commission also heard from the state Department of Public Instruction (DPI) that it expects to miss a Nov. 15 legislative deadline for its plan to move every school district and charter school onto a single statewide finance and personnel system by 2031.
No votes were taken on recommendations. Co-chair Don Martin said members will see draft recommendations Nov. 19 and could vote Dec. 14. The final report is due to the General Assembly in March 2027.
Gov. Josh Stein created the commission by executive order in March with Senate Leader Phil Berger, R-Rockingham, and House Speaker Destin Hall, R-Caldwell. Its 19 voting members and 10 nonvoting legislators have met monthly since April at NC State University’s Friday Institute.
The commission adopted its first recommendations — on early literacy, the teacher pipeline, and teacher pay — in September. Administrative operations is the second of four assignments.
Shared services
During the meeting, Friday Institute staff circulated a list of nine possible strategies that Martin said “was not intended to represent a commission consensus or recommendation.” In September, the commission had planned to have a first draft by the end of the October meeting, as Carolina Journal reported.
Members then split into three groups for about an hour, two of them in rooms open to the public but not livestreamed. The commission drew criticism in August after spending roughly two hours out of public view in virtual breakout rooms.
All three groups spent most of their time on shared services, meaning neighboring districts sharing a finance officer, cybersecurity staff, transportation, or purchasing through the state’s regional education service alliances. The groups split on whether districts should be required to participate or paid to do so.
Martin, a former Winston-Salem/Forsyth County superintendent, proposed giving districts the same budget flexibility charter schools have, including “converting position allotments to dollars,” in exchange for joining a regional system. School finance officers told the commission last month that position-based funding leads them to shift employees between budgets to capture state money.
Two groups also raised the Opportunity Scholarship program, the state’s private school voucher program, which is not part of the commission’s assignment. One asked for “more transparency, more accountability for how that money is being invested,” according to Friday Institute facilitator Mary Beth Piecham. Another discussed “potentially halting expansion of charter schools” until the state settles how local funding flows from districts to charters, Friday Institute executive director Krista Glazewski reported.
Finance system delay
Vanessa Wrenn, DPI’s chief information officer, briefed the commission on the finance, payroll, and human resources software used by school districts. The General Assembly directed DPI to replace those systems in 2017 and appropriated $29 million in 2018 and $86.5 million in 2021, according to Wrenn’s slides. Sixteen of the state’s 115 districts have moved or are moving to a new system. Fourteen use only a human resources program DPI built in the 1980s.
The 2026 state budget directs DPI to put all districts and 213 charter schools on one system, under one state-held contract, by June 30, 2031, and gives the agency until Nov. 15 to deliver a transition plan.
“We did an RFI for consultants, and all consultants said, ‘We can’t do it within that timeline,’” Wrenn said. “So we are going to propose having that plan by late December, and probably having it totally finished by January.”
DPI hired Public Consulting Group in late September to write the plan. The budget set aside an additional $54 million for the project, Wrenn said. Asked whether the law estimated savings, Wrenn said it did not. She said districts that have already changed systems have needed more staff so far. “They are not seeing those gains in year one or year two,” she said.
What’s next
Martin said six members have volunteered for a subcommittee on K-8 mathematics. The group will meet twice by Zoom and aims to have draft recommendations in the December meeting materials. In September, Brenda Berg, CEO of BEST NC, withdrew an amendment to add math instructional materials to the first set of recommendations after other members asked for more time to review the evidence.
The November meeting has been moved to Thursday, Nov. 19, because of the Thanksgiving holiday.