NC federal judge won’t throw out government suit against landlords

Apartment leasing office. Source: Matt Bango, Creative Commons

Listen to this story (6 minutes)

  • A federal judge has rejected five motions to dismiss a lawsuit against RealPage and landlords who used its products.
  • North Carolina and nine other states are pursuing the suit. The federal government also remains in the case, though it has resolved its complaint against RealPage.
  • The suit alleges that defendant landlords used RealPage's software to help keep rents higher than they would be under normal competition.

A federal judge has denied multiple requests to throw out a lawsuit North Carolina, nine other states, and the federal government filed against landlords accused of using the RealPage software to keep rents high.

US District Judge William Osteen issued a 71-page order Wednesday denying five motions to dismiss from RealPage, along with Camden Property Trust, Pinnacle Property Management Services, and Willow Bridge Property Company.

Those defendants remain in the case after the governments reached deals with other defendants: Cortland Management, Greystar Real Estate Partners, and Livcor.

The federal government’s claims against RealPage were resolved in May. But the 10 states still have claims against that company, and other state and federal claims against the remaining landlords are unresolved.

Osteen rejected the defendants’ arguments that earlier agreements have made the case moot.

“Because the voluntary decree leaves in place some of the agreement under which landlords supply confidential data … and permits RealPage to keep and train on the data it has already collected, it is not clear that pooled nonpublic data will not again be used to price competitors’ units,” he wrote. “That is the conduct at the heart of the First and Second Claims for Relief.”

“Relatedly, the Final Judgment does not address the Section 2 claims’ core,” Osteen added. “It requires RealPage to ‘retrain applicable models’ on compliant data, but it does not divest RealPage of the accumulated data reservoir that the complaint alleges maintains its monopoly, or open that reservoir to rivals.”

“This court declines to find that Defendant has carried its formidable burden by pointing to a voluntary commitment that the remaining Plaintiffs before the court cannot invoke,” the judge wrote. “Nor does RealPage contend that the Plaintiff States’ claims for civil penalties are moot; it argues only that mootness turns on the relief sought.”

Osteen emphasized that the resolution of the federal government’s claims does not apply to the states.

“No relief in that Final Judgment runs against Camden, Pinnacle, or Willow Bridge,” he wrote. “Meanwhile, the consent decrees entered into by Pinnacle and Willow Bridge are not yet adopted by this court.”

“In sum, the Final Judgment resolved the United States’ claims against RealPage, and to that extent RealPage’s motion is moot,” Osteen added. “The Plaintiff States’ claims against RealPage, Pinnacle and Willow Bridge, and all Plaintiffs’ claims against Camden are not moot.”

The judge explained how the lawsuit alleges a negative impact on competition for rental housing.

“Using competitors’ nonpublic data, the software predicts ‘with more certainty the highest price that the market will bear,’ reducing landlords’ willingness to negotiate,” Osteen wrote. “It recommends increases when competitors’ rents rise and will not recommend a price below the market minimum derived from competitors’ leases.”

“In ‘revenue protection’ mode, it responds to weak demand by reducing the number of units a landlord seeks to lease rather than lowering price, and it uses competitors’ future supply to raise unit-level prices for lease terms that would otherwise expire into a crowded market,” he added. “According to RealPage’s own description, the software ‘helps curb [landlords’] instincts to respond to down-market conditions by either dramatically lowering price or by holding price when they are losing velocity and/or occupancy.’”

“These allegations describe economically plausible anticompetitive effects flowing from the exchange,” Osteen explained. “Although Defendants argue these allegations show harm is possible, not ‘likely and significant,’ the harm alleged by Plaintiffs at this stage are plausible rather than merely conceivable.”

State Attorney General Jeff Jackson joined the lawsuit shortly after taking office in January 2025. The federal government and states sued landlords for what they say is raising rent and “frustrating the natural forces of competition” by using software that offers property owners pricing information from other landlords.

The suit alleged landlords use the RealPage software company’s algorithm to set rent prices for approximately one-third of one-bedroom and two-bedroom apartments in North Carolina.

“North Carolinians are struggling to afford their rent as it is – we won’t stand for landlords and real estate companies making the problem worse to line their own pockets,” said Jackson in a press release. “I’m suing these landlords to make sure they play by the rules so North Carolinians can get fair prices for rent.”

The landlords targeted in the original suit owned or managed more than 70,000 units across the state, especially in heavily populated metro areas such as Raleigh, Durham, Chapel Hill, and Charlotte.

The original suit alleged that RealPage exploited landlords’ sensitive information to create a pricing algorithm that violates antitrust laws. The lawsuit alleged landlords communicated with RealPage to share nonpublic information about rent prices, occupancy, discounts, and strategies for setting rents. Sharing this sensitive, nonpublic information allowed landlords to use RealPage products to set higher rent prices than would have been set by competitive market forces. 

“Renters are entitled to the benefits of vigorous competition among landlords,” according to the lawsuit. “In prosperous times, that competition should limit rent hikes; in harder times, competition should bring rent down, making housing more affordable.  RealPage has built a business out of frustrating the natural forces of competition. … RealPage sells software to landlords that collects nonpublic information from competing landlords and uses that combined information to make pricing recommendations.” 

Our stories may be republished online or in print for free. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, credit Carolina Journal and the author, and link to the original.

Related