News: CJ Exclusives

Fans of free markets give Senate tax plan high marks

Senate leader Phil Berger, at lectern, announces a $1 billion tax cut at a March 16 press conference. With him are, from left, Sens. Jerry Tillman, Tommy Tucker, Andrew Brock, and Warren Daniel. (CJ photo by Don Carrington)
Senate leader Phil Berger, at lectern, announces a $1 billion tax cut at a March 16 press conference. With him are, from left, Sens. Jerry Tillman, Tommy Tucker, Andrew Brock, and Warren Daniel. (CJ photo by Don Carrington)

Senate leaders are proposing a $1 billion middle class tax reduction plan that would lower personal and corporate income taxes, increase mortgage interest deductions, and allow for unlimited medical and charitable tax deductions.

“Under this plan, 99 percent of all individual income taxpayers in North Carolina will either receive a tax cut or pay zero income tax,” said Sen. Tommy Tucker, R-Union. He was flanked at a late morning news conference Thursday by fellow Finance Committee co-chairmen Andrew Brock, R-Davie; and Jerry Tillman, R-Randolph; and Senate leader Phil Berger, R-Rockingham.

Tucker and Berger say The Billion Dollar Middle Class Tax Cut Act would not affect the General Assembly’s ability to meet teacher pay hikes and other funding commitments already made. Nor would the sales tax base be broadened to offset the costs.

They said previous tax reforms erased budget shortfalls with surpluses, allowed for record increases in education and transportation infrastructure spending, and led to creation of about 535,000 jobs. They expect this new round of tax changes to follow that trajectory. If adopted, this plan would raise the total tax relief since 2011 to $4.5 billion.

A tax relief package also was introduced in the House on Thursday. Its sponsors say House Bill 356 would save taxpayers $64.5 million in fiscal 2017-18, and $124 million in fiscal 2018-19.

Free-market enthusiasts gave the Senate tax package high marks.

“Overall the bill is very good,” said Roy Cordato, vice president for research and resident scholar at the John Locke Foundation. “The lowering of the income tax rate is a good thing. Lowering the corporate rate is a good thing.”

“The lower the tax the better on pure liberty grounds. It advances liberty. The more income you can keep the freer you are. That should be our first argument, always,” Cordato said.

“We’re accomplishing what we need to accomplish in the state, and probably more so, to be quite honest, with all the tax cuts that have been happening. And what we have is year after year multi-hundred-million-dollar revenue surpluses, and we have a $552 million revenue surplus going into this budget cycle,” said Donald Bryson, state director for Americans for Prosperity.

“What we need to continue to do is give the money back in a good, reasoned way, but at the same time hold the line on spending, which is what this General Assembly is doing, and why we have a revenue surplus,” Bryson said.

“The plan will decrease the personal income tax from 5.499 to 5.35 (percent) and that will be one of the lowest in the Southeast, and it will help working families and small businesses, all those S-Corps who file and have to pay personal income tax,” Tucker said. An S corporation is a business that is not taxed. Its profits and losses pass on to shareholders’ personal tax returns.

The plan increases the standard tax deduction a married couple filing jointly may take on their income tax from $17,500 to $20,000, “which provides an additional significant tax reduction for small families and small businesses when coupled with the rate decrease,” Tucker said. The deduction would jump from $8,750 to $10,000 for single filers, and from $14,000 to $15,000 for a head of household.

Under this plan the cap on the itemized deduction for mortgage interest and property taxes would increase by $2,000, to $22,000. “It will eliminate the unfairness of the marriage penalty that currently exists in the mortgage interest and property tax itemized deduction,” Tucker said.

The child tax credit would be replaced with a new and larger child tax deduction ranging from $2,500 for those earning less than $40,000, to $500 for those earning $100,000 to $119,000.

Cordato was supportive of that item but dismayed that it is capped for income earners above $119,000.

“It should be for everybody regardless of income,” he said.

“From an economics perspective the reason why you will have a child tax credit or a child deduction … is to some degree that kids are an investment,” Cordato said. “So money that’s invested should not be taxed. It’s an investment whether you make $40,000 or $120,000. That principle doesn’t change based on how much you make.”

As Tucker rolled out details of reforms on the business side, he cast an apparent dig at those who claim North Carolina’s economy has been harmed by House Bill 2, the so-called bathroom bill that provoked a handful of entertainers to cancel concerts, and sports organizations to move tournaments to other states.

“We have seen a growth in business and a growth in jobs in the North Carolina economy despite this cloud everybody says is hanging over our head. The North Carolina economy continues to grow,” Tucker said.

To encourage new investment by North Carolina businesses the corporate income tax rate would be reduced over two years from 3 percent to 2.75 percent in the first year, and to 2.5 percent in 2019.

“That will make North Carolina’s rate the lowest in the U.S. for those states having a corporate income tax. Again, this plan continues to focus on those making less than $50,000 a year,” Tucker said.

Small businesses would benefit from a reduction in the franchise tax on S corporations with less than $1 million in net worth, which would be charged a flat fee of $200, a roughly $1,300 tax break, Tucker said.

The reform package would incorporate market-based sourcing, which would provide service-based businesses the same benefits that manufacturing businesses received last year through the adoption of single sales factor apportionment.

Sen. Ralph Hise, R-Mitchell, said after the news conference that the market-based sourcing would actually generate revenue for the state because more tax payments would come in from out-of-state companies than the reductions provided for in-state companies.

Under market-based sourcing, a company would pay North Carolina taxes only on that portion of its profits generated from within the state. Currently those companies pay an income tax on all revenue regardless of the state from which it comes. Under the new plan the companies would have to pay income tax to other states on revenue earned there, depending on their tax laws.

Media companies would be among those to benefit, Hise said. While their customers are mostly in North Carolina, much of their revenue might be generated from outside the state.



  • ProudlyUnaffiliated

    Good. But the best thing they could do is eliminate the state income tax and then lock that into the NC Constitution. The only escape loophole I would permit to that is if the US government repealed the 16th amendment and ceased all income tax collection at the federal level and replaced it with direct taxation of the states, all of which should happen. Then, re-instituting an NC income tax might be sensible.