News: CJ Exclusives

Goodwin Hurls Charges at Marshall at Secretary of State Forum

Incumbent Marshall denies she supported Occupy Raleigh protesters

RALEIGH — Republican Secretary of State candidate Ed Goodwin accused incumbent Democrat Elaine Marshall of backing what he labeled a subversive organization with revolutionary goals during a candidate forum Thursday night.

After threading patriotic themes and references to his military career into his earlier comments, Goodwin, a decorated Vietnam-era veteran, leveled the broadside during his closing remarks of the hour-long session.

“Ms. Marshall deeply upset me when she came by and supported the Occupy Raleigh people. As a veteran, I felt disrespected. I felt a little disgraced,” said Goodwin. He is chairman of the Chowan County Board of Commissioners and a retired special agent with the Naval Criminal Investigative Service who now runs a family farm.

“That hurt me that an elected official of the state of North Carolina would do such a thing as that. Thatorganization advocates for the overthrow of the government as we know,” Goodwin said. “That was detrimental to business. People around the country called me and wanted to know what’s happening in the state of North Carolina.”

Marshall said afterwards that she was baffled by Goodwin’s remarks.

“One time I went to the spy museum but that doesn’t make me a spy,” Marshall said.

“I attended both the Tea Party event and the Occupy event” as part of her job, she said. “I don’t belong to either one of them. I try to listen to what their frustrations are.”

Marshall said it is important in her job to understand the mood of the people.

“Unfortunately, public trust is dissipating in areas we used to think are very stable,” such as banking and churches, Marshall said, and she wanted to hear reasons for that from those who feel disaffected.

Goodwin wasn’t buying it. He became emotional, with clenched jaw and eyes moistening as he talked about risking his life in service to the country to defend everyone’s rights of association and free speech, but feeling the need to speak out for friends who died in Vietnam in defense of an American way of life the Occupy movement protests.

Marshall said she appeared in an official capacity to welcome the group to the state capital. Goodwin said people should view a video of Marshall at the event and make their own judgment about it.

“Thanks for being here,” Marshall told the crowd in the video from the October 2011 event. “My only question is what took you so long?”

In another spot she says: “Let’s keep marching the streets and showing what we really believe … self-regulatory organizations in the financial world don’t work.

“But most importantly, thank you for bringing balance to this debate, this discussion, this energy to put our country back on the right course,” she said.

The video was posted on the left-leaning Daily Kos web site by Marshall campaign manager Tiffany Reynolds Richardson.

“There are a lot of politicians trying to cozy up to Occupy Wall Street — but very few are actually hitting the streets to stand with them,” Richardson wrote in a commentary accompanying the video. “That’s why I’m proud to be working for North Carolina Secretary of State Elaine Marshall — someone who hasn’t just embraced the OWS protests, but has actually joined with them on the streets of Raleigh!

“Watch the incredible video of Elaine firing up the #Occupy Raleigh crowd last week,” Richardson wrote.

Goodwin is not the first candidate to question Marshall’s link to the Occupy movement. Pilot Mountain funeral home executive A.J. Daoud, Goodwin’s Republican primary opponent, raised the issue at a meeting of the Surry County Republicans earlier this year to announce his candidacy, according to the Mount Airy News.

“I don’t know how you guys feel about it, but it makes me feel sick to my stomach that the secretary of state is being endorsed by Occupy, who harm our police officers and promote violence,” the newspaper quoted Daoud as saying. Daoud is a former police officer.

But most of the night was spent addressing business-related questions during the question-and-answer session of the forum, sponsored by the Wake County League of Women Voters and the North Carolina Center for Voter Education. The secretary of state oversees many state government functions related to business and economic matters.

Marshall touted policies she implemented to take politics out of the office, and to provide what she believes to be the best educational training of notary publics of any state in the nation.

She repeatedly drove home the message that she was modernizing the office with electronic technology. That makes business creation faster, and accommodates real estate and financial interests in seeking information vital to their daily work, she said.

She said her office has been vigorous in rooting out fraud, identifying bootlegging businesses and Ponzi schemes that take money away from legitimate businesses and prey on vulnerable seniors.

“In the last four years alone we’ve restored over $1 billion to North Carolinians,” Marshall said.

If re-elected, Marshall said, she will continue efforts to strengthen state lobbying laws so that they mirror federal tax code definitions and federal lobbying laws, and fight against growing efforts to roll back existing lobbying statutes.

Goodwin said much could be done to ease the burden on business in North Carolina in areas such as regulatory costs, labor force preparedness, growth prospects, economic climate and quality of life.

“We need to do something about those to improve our position in the Southeast,” he said.

He favors continuing modernization of the Secretary of State’s Office, but believes Marshall doesn’t get out from behind the desk enough.

He said he would regularly visit Chamber of Commerce officials, economic development directors, county managers, county commissioners and business interests around the state.

From that he would “take the low-hanging fruit . . . to the state legislature and say, ‘Ladies and gentlemen, this is what needs to be improved and changed to improve the business climate of the state” and get an immediate economic jolt.

Goodwin said the state’s port infrastructure is one area where improvement is needed. He gave an example of an agricultural business in Chowan County that sends 53 trucks at a time to Virginia to ship its goods. All those port costs, usage fees and other charges go out of state instead of to North Carolina.

The candidates differed on tax incentives for business.

“I do not like incentives,” Goodwin said “I consider that not a good expenditure of the taxpayer money.”

“Given the current climate, it is necessary,” Marshall said. “I don’t particularly care for it.”

Dan E. Way is an associate editor of Carolina Journal.