News: CJ Exclusives

Silent Sam may get new home at UNC-Chapel Hill historic center

Onlookers view the base of "Silent Sam" Aug. 20, 2018, the day after protesters removed the Confederate monument from its post at UNC-Chapel Hill. (CJ photo by Don Carrington)
Onlookers view the base of "Silent Sam" Aug. 20, 2018, the day after protesters removed the Confederate monument from its post at UNC-Chapel Hill. (CJ photo by Don Carrington)

Silent Sam soon may return to campus after the UNC-Chapel Hill Board of Trustees approved a recommendation to rehouse the Confederate memorial in a new, on-campus historic education center near UNC Medical Center.

The Board of Trustees met Monday, Dec. 3, to approve a recommendation to determine Silent Sam’s fate, months after protesters toppled the statue.  

“We do want to get this right, and we believe we have,” UNC-Chapel Hill Chancellor Carol Folt said.

The statue — built in 1913 to honor UNC students who fought in the Civil War — was taken down by protesters Aug. 19 and put in storage by university officials. A week later, the UNC Board of Governors gave the UNC-Chapel Hill board 90 days to develop a lawful and lasting plan to restore and preserve Silent Sam. The UNC board later got an extension until Dec. 3 to complete the plan and submit it to the Board of Governors for consideration.

UNC-Chapel Hill officials spent weeks deciding what to do with Silent Sam. They had to balance the demands of state law with the needs of the campus. While several board members and Folt first preferred moving the statue off-campus, current law prevents that action without legislative approval. Instead, Folt detailed a four-part plan to preserve the statue and provide historical context, while also ensuring public safety on campus.

Silent Sam won’t return to its pedestal at the university’s McCorkle Place, but it could move indoors. The university plans to open a new center for history and education at Odum Village, where the statue will be available for public viewing or other educational purposes.

“As you go through the law, as you go through the resolution of the Board of Governors, as you go through the resolution of our Board of Trustees, we believe that an on-campus, indoor location … is an appropriate measure to preserve the monument and is completely consistent with the governing law,” Mark Merritt, the university’s legal counsel, said.

The project will cost $5.3 million to complete with an additional $800,000 in annual operating costs. It will feature state-of-the-art security measures, interactive exhibits, and teaching materials. The plan also calls for creating McCorkle Place Gateway, a commemorative space for reflection on the university’s past, present, and future with plaques and historical markers.

The only board members dissenting from the plan were Allie Ray McCullen and student member Savannah Putnam.

“I simply can’t support putting a Confederate monument back on campus,” Putnam said.

Odum Village, south of the Dean Smith Center and the main UNC Health Care campus, was built in the 1960s as apartments for graduate students and students with children. The apartments were demolished in 2016. The property hasn’t been used since.

UNC System Board of Governors Chair Harry Smith released a statement in response to the recommendation.

“The UNC Board of Governors today received recommendations for the disposition and preservation of the confederate monument know as Silent Sam,” Smith said. “This four-part plan is thorough and detailed, and we are grateful for the time and energy that the UNC-Chapel Hill Board of Trustees and UNC-Chapel Hill Chancellor Carol Folt took to develop these recommendations.”

The UNC BOG will discuss the recommendation during its Dec. 14 meeting and decide whether to approve the plan. The N.C. Historical Commission will also have to sign off on the recommendations.

Gov. Roy Cooper, in Greensboro on Monday for the N.C. Farm Bureau Convention, weighed in on the recommended plan for Silent Sam.

“I believe those monuments should not be in a place of honor, but should be studied as a part of history in a museum,” Cooper said.

  • civilwar 12

    Put the anarchist libs in the historic center and the statue back up where it was.

    • Junius Daniel


  • ProudlyUnaffiliated

    Anything other than putting the statue back up as is (with perhaps a small fence or a short, tasteful wall surrounding it with 24/7 camera surveillance to make prosecutions and student evictions easier) will be a capitulation to the vandals. What happens when you capitulate to criminal evil? We know, we all know.

    • Junius Daniel

      Apparently those in charge of our state misst that chapter in the history book, Dear Unaffiliated!

  • Junius Daniel


    So said Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain, this as he waved the agreement he had signed with Adolf Hitler, after returning home from Munich in 1938.

    And so it is with this – something which virtually guarantees the next sad event – just as the lack of law-enforcement in the Durham incident led to this incident in Chapel- Hill.

    What this agreement does is show those who wish to make a bloodless conquest of North Carolina can regard the law as merely a starting point for negotiations, and that, despite all the claims to the contrary by those charged with enforcing our laws and defending our culture and people, the law will either not entirely, or not quite, be enforcet.

    And when The Law is not enforcet, what happens?

    Nothing good that I can think of.

    And when that nothing good thing inevitable comes to pass, people will be aghast at what has occurred, and family and friends of those who have been hurt, and or will be long jailed, will be left to bear the burden of the suffering for the simple fact that those in charge of this state could not find it within themselves to do anything more than kick the can up the road.

    Of course, I do so hope I am wrong…

  • ProudlyUnaffiliated

    “I believe those monuments should not be in a place of honor, but should be studied as a part of history in a museum,” Cooper said.

    Governor, we are putting Silent Sam back up on the UNC campus, which is clearly not a place of honor.