Voter ID, tax cap amendments from 2018 face NC Appeals Court hearing

Carolina Journal photo

Listen to this story (15 minutes)

  • The North Carolina Court of Appeals tackled Wednesday a lawsuit challenging state constitutional amendments voters approved in 2018. One lowered the state income tax cap. The other mandated photo identification for in-person voters.
  • Voters in this year's elections face new constitutional amendments addressing similar topics.
  • The North Carolina State Conference of the NAACP is asking appellate judges to overturn a trial court's 2025 ruling upholding both 2018 amendments.

The North Carolina Court of Appeals is tackling a seven-year-old legal battle over state constitutional amendments voters approved in 2018 to lower the state income tax cap and require photo identification for in-person voters.

The court fight prompted the first season of Carolina Journal’s “Extreme Injustice” podcast.

Voters heading to the polls during this year’s election campaign are addressing similar issues to those presented on the 2018 ballot. For one current ballot measure, North Carolinians will decide whether to lower the state’s income tax cap to 3.5%. The other measure asks voters whether to extend current constitutional voter ID requirements to all voters, including those who cast absentee ballots by mail.

A three-judge Appeals Court panel heard nearly an hour of oral arguments Wednesday about two measures approved eight years ago. One lowered the previous income tax cap from 10% to 7%. The second mandated photo ID for in-person voting.

The North Carolina State Conference of the NAACP is asking appellate judges to reverse a unanimous bipartisan three-judge trial court ruling from September 2025. Trial judges upheld both amendments. Critics argue that the trial court ignored a state Supreme Court ruling allowing the case to proceed.

“For our judiciary to function, we need to have predictable rules of civil procedure that are applies evenly across all cases,” argued Kym Meyer, a lawyer for the NAACP. “Lower courts need to respect the mandates of the courts above them. None of this should be controversial, yet we’re here today because the three-judge panel in this case defied a clearly articulated directive from the Supreme Court and then ran roughshod through the basic requirements of rule 12(c).”

“Today, all we are asking the court to do is to restore certainty and judicial order,” Meyer added. “There is no need to get into the merits of the remedial phase of this case. Indeed, it would be premature to do so.”

“The Supreme Court in this case gave the trial court a test and a job,” answered Martin Warf, representing the state legislative leaders who are defending the amendments. “Apply the test to two amendments that more than 2 million North Carolinians ratified in 2018. The three-judge panel did exactly that.”

“Isn’t it up to the trial court to decide what type of evidence may be relevant?” Chief Judge Chris Dillon asked early in the arguments. “Could the trial court determine, ‘You know we’ve got this question of law that just resolves the whole case … there is no evidence that’s relevant, and therefore, I’m going to give a hearing on all relevant evidence, which is nothing?’”

“If the current constitutional amendments that are on the ballot right now in this election were to pass, wouldn’t that render this moot?” asked Judge Donna Stroud.

Stroud also asked about the plaintiffs’ attempt to throw out amendments approved in a statewide vote.

“So the legislation that the legislature passes without the input from the voters — even though it’s racially gerrymandered — is OK, but the legislation the legislature passes with the input of the voters is, like, maybe OK if it passes the test?” she asked.

Top lawmakers responded to the NAACP’s arguments in a July Appeals Court brief.

“This appeal does not present the constitutional crisis that Plaintiff-Appellant describes,” legislative leaders’ lawyers wrote. “Plaintiff frames this case as a story of lawless lower courts defying the North Carolina Supreme Court and running roughshod over the Rules of Civil Procedure. That framing cannot survive contact with the record.”

“What Plaintiff actually asked the trial court to do was extraordinary: to erase from the North Carolina Constitution two amendments that the people of this State ratified by wide margins in November 2018,” lawmakers’ brief continued. “The three-judge panel declined to take that step because Plaintiff cannot meet its burden as a matter of law, and it was right to do so.”

In the years since the NAACP filed suit, “the legal landscape governing this dispute has been settled by controlling decisions of this State’s appellate courts,” legislative lawyers noted. The state Supreme Court’s 2023 decision in Holmes v. Moore “upheld the very Voter ID framework Plaintiff attacks and did so applying the same presumption of constitutionality that governs here.”

The NAACP is asking the Appeals Court to reverse the trial judges’ decision.

“While this case ultimately involves questions of great constitutional significance, this appeal centers only on basic rules of civil procedure,” the NAACP’s lawyers wrote in May. “The question before this Court is whether lower court judges, who disagree with a prior ruling of the North Carolina Supreme Court, can abuse the rules of civil procedure to manufacture an outcome they prefer. To restore order and confidence to North Carolina’s judiciary, this Court must soundly reject the lower courts’ lawless acts.”

In August 2022, when the state Supreme Court had a 4-3 Democratic majority, the high court decided with a party-line vote to send the case back to a trial judge for additional findings.

The trial court “ignored this clear mandate” in deciding to send the case to a three-judge panel, according to the NAACP’s brief. That panel then ruled in favor of Republican legislative leaders defending the challenged amendments.

“The judgment not only throws into disarray the well-established hierarchy of our judicial system, but also makes a mockery of the North Carolina Rules of Civil Procedure,” the NAACP’s lawyers argued. “It is well established that lower courts should follow the mandate of higher courts strictly, and not second-guess their decisions.”

“By throwing out the rules of civil procedure, ignoring our State’s highest court, and contradicting the Superior Court’s rulings and fact-findings in this very case, both the Superior Court judge and the panel replaced a rule-bound legal process with arbitrary and unmoored diktat,” the brief added.

Plaintiffs in the case now titled North Carolina NAACP v. Hall had argued that the two challenged amendments unconstitutionally discriminated against minorities.

“Plaintiff’s pleadings fail to establish that ‘no set of circumstances exists under which the act(s) would be valid,’” according to the three-judge panel’s 15-page court order rejecting the NAACP’s arguments. “As such, Plaintiffs pleadings have failed to satisfy the burden of proof as to facial unconstitutionality.”

“As a matter of law, after considering all allegations contained in Plaintiffs pleadings except for conclusions of law and legally impossible facts, Plaintiff fails to meet its burden of proof of beyond a reasonable doubt that the legislature enacted the Voter ID Amendment with discriminatory intent and that the legislation actually produces a meaningful disparate impact along racial lines,” the order continued.

“As a matter of law, after considering all allegations contained in Plaintiffs pleadings, except for conclusions of law and legally impossible facts, Plaintiff fails to meet its burden of proof of beyond a reasonable doubt that the legislature enacted Tax Cap Amendment with discriminatory intent and the legislation actually produces a meaningful disparate impact along racial lines,” the judges wrote.

Superior Court Judges James Gregory Bell, Michael Duncan, and Cynthia Sturges issued their decision more than 10 months after hearing oral arguments in the case. Bell is a Democrat based in Robeson County. Duncan of Wilkes County and Sturges of Franklin County are both Republicans.

In an August 2024 memorandum, lawyers for top lawmakers explained why they believed the three-judge Superior Court panel should end the case.

“This matter is on remand to determine whether two amendments proposed by the 2018 North Carolina General Assembly and adopted overwhelmingly by the people of North Carolina should be erased from the Constitution,” lawmakers’ lawyers wrote. “In order for the Court to take such an extraordinary step, Plaintiff must prove … that the amendments have ‘a substantial risk’ of (1) immunizing legislators from democratic accountability; (2) perpetuating the continued exclusion of a category of voters from the democratic process; or (3) constituting intentional racial discrimination.”

“Both amendments at issue here must be left in place because neither amendment meets these factors,” lawmakers’ lawyers argued. “This three-factor equitable test is not adjudicated in a vacuum. Rather, to prevail, Plaintiff must show ‘that there are no circumstances under which the[se] statute[s] might be constitutional.’”

“Newer precedent from the North Carolina Supreme Court regarding photographic identification to vote bears on this Court’s analysis, as does the traditional principles of constitutional review,” the memo added. “It is for these legal reasons that Defendants submit that Plaintiffs claim to invalidate the tax cap amendment … and the voter ID amendment … presently fails as a matter of law.”

State Supreme Court Democrats agreed in 2022 that amendments placed on the election ballot by a racially gerrymandered General Assembly could be deemed invalid, regardless of voters’ response to those amendments.

The NAACP plaintiffs labeled the Republican-led General Assembly a “usurper.”  High court Democrats endorsed much of the plaintiffs’ argument but left the final decision about the amendments’ fate in the hands of the Wake County Superior Court.

Eight months later, after the state Supreme Court had shifted to a 5-2 Republican majority, the new court upheld the state’s voter ID law. Lawmakers had approved the law in 2018, just weeks after voters endorsed the ID constitutional amendment.

That April 2023 state Supreme Court decision prompted the North Carolina State Board of Elections to implement the voter ID requirement. Elections officials first requested ID from voters during 2023 municipal elections. The ID requirement remains in place for voters today.

Wake County Superior Court Judge Bryan Collins rejected both constitutional amendments in February 2019. The NC Court of Appeals later reversed Collins’ ruling. The 4-3 Democrat-led Supreme Court’s August 2022 decision reversed the Appeals Court’s decision.

“The issue is whether legislators elected from unconstitutionally racially gerrymandered districts possess unreviewable authority to initiate the process of changing the North Carolina Constitution, including in ways that would allow those same legislators to entrench their own power, insulate themselves from political accountability, or discriminate against the same racial group who were excluded from the democratic process by the unconstitutionally racially gerrymandered districts,” wrote Justice Anita Earls for the then-Democratic majority.

“We conclude that article I, sections 2 and 3 of the North Carolina Constitution impose limits on these legislators’ authority to initiate the process of amending the constitution under these circumstances,” Earls added. “Nonetheless, we also conclude that the trial court’s order in this case invalidating the two challenged amendments swept too broadly.”

Republican justices objected. “[T]he majority nullifies the will of the people and precludes governance by the majority,” according to dissenters.

“At issue today is not what our constitution says. The people of North Carolina settled that question when they amended the constitution to include the Voter ID and Tax Cap Amendments,” Justice Phil Berger Jr. wrote in dissent. “These amendments were placed on the November 2018 ballot by the constitutionally required three-fifths majority in the legislature. On November 6, 2018, the citizens of North Carolina voted overwhelmingly to approve the North Carolina Voter ID Amendment and the North Carolina Income Tax Cap Amendment. More than 2,000,000 people, or 55.49% of voters, voted in favor of Voter ID, while the Tax Cap Amendment was approved by more than 57% of North Carolina’s voters.”

“Instead, the majority engages in an inquiry that is judicially forbidden — what should our constitution say? This question is designated solely to the people and the legislature,” Berger added. “The majority concedes that constitutional procedures were followed, yet they invalidate more than 4.1 million votes and disenfranchise more than 55% of North Carolina’s electorate.”

The John Locke Foundation’s then-CEO, Amy Cooke, also criticized the 4-3 decision in August 2022.

“The ‘Usurper Four’ Democrat majority has gone scorched earth on the state constitution and the will of millions of North Carolina voters,” Cooke said in a prepared statement. “This decision, crafted by notorious progressive idealogue Anita Earls, is designed to appease the Democrats’ far-left activist base — a small but well-funded base that openly rejects the very popular voter ID law and taxpayer protections. These four justices — Anita Earls, Sam Ervin, Michael Morgan, and Robin Hudson — are guilty of voter suppression.” 

Hudson retired from the court when her term expired in 2022. Voters ousted Ervin in the 2022 election. Morgan retired from the court in 2023 and ran for the Democratic nomination for governor. He lost in the March 2024 primary. Only Earls remains on the state Supreme Court from Cooke’s “Usurper Four.”

NC NAACP v. Moore was the subject of season one of the John Locke Foundation’s “Extreme Injustice” podcast. The case is documented at ExtremeInjustice.com. The podcast focused on efforts to disqualify Berger and fellow Republican Justice Tamara Barringer from taking part in the case. The state Supreme Court ultimately decided to allow Berger and Barringer to make their own decisions about whether to hear the case.

Our stories may be republished online or in print for free. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, credit Carolina Journal and the author, and link to the original.

Related