Opinion: Daily Journal

Setting Limits for State Spending Growth

RALEIGH — The majority of the state’s operations are funded through the General Fund. There are, though, some major components of the state’s expenditure that are located outside the General Fund. In short, the General Fund amounts to around $20 billion, while total state spending amounts to approximately $51 billion.

The major differences between these two budgets are highways and the Highway Trust Fund, federal funding, and some debt service, which are all located outside the General Fund.

Federal funds account for more than 30 percent of the state’s overall budget, and contrary to popular belief, “free” federal money is not really free. Every tax dollar Washington sends to North Carolina is a dollar taken from taxpayers in North Carolina and the other states.

Economists have found that federal subsidies to the states lead to higher state taxes and spending in the long run, because the federal “seed money” creates a demand for more government with current and future commitments.

Over the last few decades, the state’s spending priorities have been public K-12 education and health and human services. These two items make up more than 60 percent of the state budget.

Within state government there are many areas that have been growing exponentially over the last decade. As the state continues to increase spending, the effectiveness of that spending is being questioned.

This has led some lawmakers to call for spending constraints that would limit increases in General Fund spending to a rate of inflation plus population growth, in addition to any voter-approved changes each year. Since 1980, North Carolina’s population has grown an average of 1.7 percent, and inflation has increased an average of 2.2 percent annually. Concurrently, the General Fund has grown an average of 5 percent per year.

The overall goal of a spending constraint would be to allow for natural growth associated with population and inflation, while keeping overall spending under control. In addition, polls reveal that a majority of North Carolinians supports a cap on state spending using these parameters.

While government can fulfill useful roles in society by providing protection and public goods, there is a tendency for government to undertake unnecessary activities as it expands, which in turn diminishes economic freedom. The focus of the state’s budget should be on core government services.

Sarah Curry is Director of Fiscal Policy Studies for the John Locke Foundation.